PCD vs Carbide in Non-Ferrous Machining

Tools wearing out every 200-500 parts, constant machine downtime, unsatisfactory surface finishes on aluminum and brass. If you recognize these problems, Polycrystalline Diamond (PCD) could be the breakthrough you’re looking for.

The Problem Everyone Knows

Machining high-silicon aluminum alloys, lead-free brass, or CFRP composites with traditional tools often means:

  • Frequent tool changes (every 200-1000 parts)
  • Limited cutting speeds to preserve the tool
  • Surface roughness requiring rework
  • Hidden costs from machine downtime and labor

The Solution: PCD Tools

Polycrystalline Diamond Compact combines diamond hardness (6000-7000 HV10) with the robustness of a tungsten carbide substrate.

The Game-Changing Numbers:

  • Hardness: 4× higher than carbide (6000 vs 1500 HV10) 
  • Thermal conductivity: 8× better (700 vs 90 W/mK) 
  • Friction on aluminum: 75% lower (0.05 vs 0.20)

Real Results on Critical Materials

MaterialCarbide SpeedPCD SpeedTool LifeRoughness Ra
Al-Si 14%350-450 m/min1800-2100 m/min×10-250.1-0.3 µm
Brass CuZn21Si3P400-500 m/min1200-1800 m/min×15-200.12-0.18 µm
CFRP 60% fiber250-400 m/min×8-120.2 µm

Sources: Kennametal 2022, Amaral et al. 2018, ZYsuperhard 2023

Optimal Operating Parameters

Aluminum-Silicon Milling

  • Speed: 1500-2000 m/min
  • Feed: 0.10-0.15 mm/tooth
  • Depth: ≤ 0.8 × diameter
  • Notes: Lubricant optional

Lead-Free Brass Turning

  • Speed: 1000-1400 m/min
  • Feed: 0.15-0.25 mm/tooth
  • Notes: Dry machining recommended

CFRP Drilling

  • Speed: 250-350 m/min
  • Feed: 0.08-0.12 mm/tooth
  • Depth: ≤ 3 × diameter
  • Notes: Exit backing plate mandatory

When NOT to Use PCD

Watch these limitations:

  • Never on steels (carbon-iron diffusion above 700°C)
  • Avoid interrupted cuts (reduced toughness: 3-5 MPa√m)
  • Low-rigidity machines won’t exploit high speeds
  • Very small diameters where maximum toughness is needed
  • Thermal shocks require gradual increase

FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Does PCD work on pure aluminum? A: Yes, but major benefits show on high-silicon alloys (>8%) where carbide suffers more.

Q: Can I use the same parameters as carbide? A: No, PCD requires much higher speeds. Start gradually and increase to optimal parameters.

Q: How long does a PCD tool last? A: On Al-Si typically 10-25× longer than carbide, but depends on specific application.

Conclusions

PCD isn’t the universal solution, but on high-silicon aluminum alloys, lead-free brass, and composites it offers decisive advantages:

  • Tripled speeds 
  • Tool life 10-25× higher 
  • Excellent surface finishes

Our clients

Explore

Contact us

    * Required field